Close a Stalled Enterprise Deal With Competing Stakeholders and a Shrinking Budget
The Opportunity You are a senior Enterprise AE at Vantara, a B2B SaaS company that sells an AI-powered procurement intelligence platform. Vantara helps enterprise procurement and finance teams automate spend analysis, flag supplier risk,…
Create a free account to upload your work. Your progress saves as a draft until you submit.
What You'll Be Doing
The Opportunity
You are a senior Enterprise AE at Vantara, a B2B SaaS company that sells an AI-powered procurement intelligence platform. Vantara helps enterprise procurement and finance teams automate spend analysis, flag supplier risk, and accelerate sourcing cycles. ACV typically ranges from $180K–$600K. You carry a $3.2M annual quota.
You are 60 days into a deal with Meridian Industrial — a $4.8B industrial manufacturer with 12,000 employees across North America and Europe. Here is what you know:
The Account
-
VP of Procurement (Dana Reyes) is your primary champion. Dana has been pushing internally for a procurement modernization initiative for 18 months. She is bought in on Vantara and has been running an internal pilot with her team of 8.
-
CFO (Marcus Webb) controls the budget. He has attended one demo but has been non-committal. His EA has twice rescheduled a follow-up call. Finance is under pressure to reduce discretionary spend by 12% this quarter.
-
VP of IT (Priya Nair) has raised InfoSec concerns about Vantara's data residency model. She has not formally blocked the deal but has not signed off on security review.
-
The current contract proposal is $340K ACV for a 3-year term. Meridian's procurement team is using your pilot tool daily and has shared informal feedback that it has saved them roughly 15 hours/week in manual spend analysis.
The Complications
-
Competitive threat: Three weeks ago, Dana mentioned that Meridian received an unsolicited outreach from Coupa — a well-known competitor with deeper brand recognition in the procurement space. Coupa offered a 'strategic partnership' meeting with Meridian's CPO next week. You don't know what they proposed.
-
Budget objection: During your last call with Dana, she said Marcus Webb's team has asked procurement to 'right-size all vendor commitments.' Dana expects he will push back on the 3-year term and may propose cutting to a 1-year contract or reducing seats. Dana has advised you not to call Marcus directly until she 'sets the stage' — but that call has not happened in two weeks.
-
Timeline pressure: Meridian's fiscal year ends in 47 days. Dana has told you that any new vendor contracts must be approved by the CFO and submitted to legal 10 business days before fiscal close. That means you have approximately 27 business days to get to a signed contract — or the deal slips to next fiscal year, which Dana says would likely kill momentum.
-
Internal constraint: Your company's deal desk requires a formal security review sign-off from Meridian IT before a contract can be executed. You cannot waive this requirement. Your InfoSec team has offered to run a one-day accelerated review if Priya Nair agrees to participate.
How Your Work Will Be Scored
What to Submit
Executive Brief
Format: .pdf, .doc, .docx, .rtf, .txt, .md
Produce a concise executive-facing communication artifact addressed to Marcus Webb (CFO). This should be a document, email, or structured brief (your choice of format) that you would actually send or bring into a meeting.
Your Executive Brief must:
-
Lead with business outcome — not Vantara product features or company overview
-
Speak Marcus's language — address the 12% discretionary spend reduction pressure directly
-
Make a specific, timed ask (do not end without a clear next step)
-
Be 2 pages or fewer — Marcus will not read more
Sign in to upload files
Deal Assessment
Format: .pdf, .doc, .docx, .rtf, .txt, .md
A structured written document with exactly three sections. Do not merge or reorder them.
Section A — Deal Strategy & Close Plan (300–450 words)
In this section, provide your analysis and plan for closing this deal within the 27-business-day window. Your Section A should address:
-
Stakeholder assessment: who is the economic buyer, who is the champion, and who is the blocker — and what that means for your sequencing
-
Your close plan: a sequence of specific milestones and next actions with timing, not a list of activities
-
Deal risks: at least two named risks and your specific mitigation strategy for each
-
Qualification assessment: is this deal closable in the window? What assumptions are you making, and where are your gaps?
Section B — Competitive & Objection Strategy (250–400 words)
In this section, address the two most significant deal threats: the Coupa competitive risk and the CFO budget objection.
For the competitive threat: What is your strategy for the Coupa situation? Be specific — 'differentiate on value' is not a strategy. Name the specific dynamic you are trying to control, and what you will do in the next 5 business days.
For the budget objection: When Marcus proposes a 1-year contract or a seat reduction, how do you respond? Walk through your objection handling approach — do not default to discounting. Explain your reframe and the specific language or data you would use.
Section C — AI Usage Log (Mandatory)*
This is not a trick. We want to see how you work with AI — not whether you used it.
In this section, document your AI collaboration process. For each significant interaction with an AI tool, briefly note:
- What you asked the AI to help with
- What it gave you
- What you kept, changed, or rejected — and why
Three interactions documented is sufficient. The log does not need to be exhaustive.
Sign in to upload files
Video Walkthrough
Format: .mp4, .mov, .webm
Record your walkthrough as an MP4 or MOV file and upload it directly on the Provn platform as a separate file.
Structure your video as follows:
-
Opening (60 seconds): Summarise the deal situation and your overall recommended strategy — what is the most important thing you need to accomplish in the next 10 business days and why?
-
Executive Brief walkthrough (2–3 minutes): Walk through your Executive Brief. Explain the choices you made — particularly why you led with what you led with, and what you are asking Marcus to do.
-
Deal & competitive strategy (2–3 minutes): Explain your close plan and your approach to the Coupa threat and the CFO objection. What are you most confident about, and where is your biggest risk?
-
Mandatory AI question (1–2 minutes): "Walk me through one moment where you disagreed with, pushed back on, or redirected what the AI gave you — and what you did instead. Name the specific moment. Explain what the AI produced that didn't meet the bar, what you did differently, and why."
-
Reflection (30–60 seconds): What would you do differently if you had more time or more information?
Sign in to upload files
Create a free account to upload your work. Your progress saves as a draft until you submit.
On this page